At this point I see the two SnY games as well, just that. Two separate games.
They have different names.
Shiro No Yakata. White Mansion.
Shiratane no Tou. Tower of Shiratane.
Let's be honest, we mostly play stuff with Zell23's art because we want the art and clean animation. That the games happen to be perfectly servicable action titles doesn't matter a great deal, not that it isn't enjoyed by us or anything but we're going to be getting 2x the animated content and 2x more monstergirl species of all shapes and sizes.
Hmm... There are other pixel artists I like much more than Zell personally.
I like Zell not just because of his art but his sexual proclivities. FOBS has really interesting sexual scenarios and positions that jive well with me.
Stuff like getting caught by the mummy. Doing the Quiz. Jumping away from the teleporter.
If Zell did maledom I honestly wouldn't like him or even know his name.
Admittedly... I do kinda wish Ansala's SnY would keep some of Zell's spooky monster girl concept, just hoping it'll be dial down the monster in monstergirl some so it would be basically a lite version of Zell's version. But things appear to moving towards this being a SA2.
I don't think the spookyness is completely gone. Apparently, the "combat" system in the Ansalafied SnY isn't all that heavy.
I doubt the girls will lose all of their monstrous nature too.
I think it's a bit extreme to call it SA2 when Succubus Affection had no level design or consistent world-design.
Though it'll definitely feel more Succubus Affectiony since Ansala's at the helm.
The MC can sexually initiate with some of the female NPCs so there's some male assertive content there, and the lack of other male NPCs really takes away from SnY's original identity.
Also, could not care less for that turn-based rpg he wants to do. Years ago Zell showed a proof of concept of an ARPG project he was working on, and well... I'm way more interested in that. Sadly it's dead and buried though, quite literally because of flash going down rendering it inoperable.
This is my strongest disagreement, but that's just up to tastes!
I like turn-based games because of what it means for challenge and encounter design. Especially on a balance level.
Action games... especially action games with femdom elements never do it for me that well, because action design is meant to make the player feel powerful. Turn-based is meant to slow down encounters, and put you on the same level as your opponent.
That's just my opinion though.
Wait there's 2 different SnY ?
No. There's only 1. Shiro No Yakata is in development with Ansala as the project lead on his Ci-En.