- Joined
- Nov 10, 2008
- Messages
- 4,912
- Reputation score
- 1,795
Re: Are games art? A popular debate that I've recently revisited
When in doubt, Obe's trolling.
When in doubt, Obe's trolling.
See, now that makes much more sense. The original way you had said it, it almost sounded like "Braid is art, nothing else in this medium is", which is the main reason I snapped at ye.My purpose of dropping Halo/CoD out of the discussion was the off tangent it was leading towards about realism of CoD being a deciding factor on artistic quality. And as your successor posts,
This is why someone can say CoD or Halo is not art. Because as shiny and nice as it is, it is not, in itself, a piece of art, despite having beauty inside it (among other arguable artistic qualities). While a game such as Braid, which exists specifically for it's storytelling method and the fullness of what it represents, to not be called art, would be like saying the Mona Lisa isn't art because it's just paint and a canvas, or like saying that Romeo and Juliet can't be considered art anymore because it's reprinted in highschool textbooks.
What I'm saying is, the medium cannot decide if something is or is not art.
My purpose for stepping in here was to end the debate of if games can be art, because the answer is a resounding "Yes."
The discussion should, if it is to continue, simply be redirected into more of a question on which games are art.
p.s. my comment "shame on you", was meant as humorous barb, and encouragement to go play what is a very good game. Not actually berating anyone for not playing it. And if you call that intro post a good way to start a thread, I think I'll take your dislike of me as a compliment.
And now, I am out of here, as I'm not feeding the troll anymore.
DID SOMEONE JUST SHIT ON MAH HALO?...Halo is not art.
Nah they said it's not art. The sandwich I'm eating isn't art either, and if that makes it shit then I'm very worried.DID SOMEONE JUST SHIT ON MAH HALO?
Agreed. I particularly liked the point about controversy over 'modern art'. While hardly an art buff, a lot of the things that attract attention from the media in 'modern art' I would quite happily rate below one or two games I could mention - notably The Path.Personally, I agree withYou must be registered to see the linkstake on the matter.
Especially the part about trying to impregnate a dishwasher.
Then again, I guess it depends on the kind of dishwasher...