Shadow Word: Porn
Jungle Girl
- Joined
- Oct 12, 2016
- Messages
- 28
- Reputation score
- 6
Re: Princess Sacrifice - Eng Translation (WIP)
So, I’m wondering about the translation for ブヒヒッ and similar onomatopoeias. It's the sound a pig makes (or a pig-man, in this case: an orc.) I could use other people's thoughts.
The two translations I’ve seen so far are *grunt* and “oink”, and I have problems with both of those. The issue with *grunt* is that it’s not really clear that that’s a pig sound. Humans grunt too, and it sounds totally different, so the word doesn’t really get across the idea of orcs being pig-men.
“Oink” certainly does, but my problem with that is that it sounds comedic. Orcs going “oink-oink” is totally appropriate in a light-hearted fantasy anime like Slayers or Dragon Half or even Words Worth, but it doesn’t seem fitting for a brutal rape/torture scene, and I’m worried it'll break the mood. This is a dark and vicious world, and the orcs are not very nice people.
I’ve come up with a third possible translation, which is *snort*. I think that’s my favorite so far, since it’s more of an “animal sound” than *grunt*, and also doesn’t instantly turn the scene into a comedy. It's still not perfect, I just can't come up with anything better.
So... any thoughts on the right way to translate orc/pig noises?
So, I’m wondering about the translation for ブヒヒッ and similar onomatopoeias. It's the sound a pig makes (or a pig-man, in this case: an orc.) I could use other people's thoughts.
The two translations I’ve seen so far are *grunt* and “oink”, and I have problems with both of those. The issue with *grunt* is that it’s not really clear that that’s a pig sound. Humans grunt too, and it sounds totally different, so the word doesn’t really get across the idea of orcs being pig-men.
“Oink” certainly does, but my problem with that is that it sounds comedic. Orcs going “oink-oink” is totally appropriate in a light-hearted fantasy anime like Slayers or Dragon Half or even Words Worth, but it doesn’t seem fitting for a brutal rape/torture scene, and I’m worried it'll break the mood. This is a dark and vicious world, and the orcs are not very nice people.
I’ve come up with a third possible translation, which is *snort*. I think that’s my favorite so far, since it’s more of an “animal sound” than *grunt*, and also doesn’t instantly turn the scene into a comedy. It's still not perfect, I just can't come up with anything better.
So... any thoughts on the right way to translate orc/pig noises?
Last edited: